Key Highlights
- Strategy (MSTR) is excluded despite its large size and profits, as its heavy reliance on Bitcoin is seen as too volatile and risky for the index
- Robinhood joins the S&P 500 after its stock surged impressively in 2025
- This decision shows that companies that facilitate crypto trading are gaining mainstream acceptance
The group that manages the index announced on Friday that the trading app Robinhood (HOOD) is in, while the Bitcoin-heavy company Strategy (MSTR) was, once again, left out. In the S&P 500 rebalancing announcement, the prestigious S&P 500 index is getting a new member.
This decision is a tale of two companies linked to cryptocurrency. One, Robinhood, is being welcomed into the club of America’s biggest and most important companies. The other, Strategy, is being kept at the door, for now.
JUST IN: Strategy was NOT included in the S&P 500’s quarterly rebalancing. pic.twitter.com/Ymzj2bA3nD
— The ₿itcoin Therapist (@TheBTCTherapist) September 5, 2025
Robinhood Achieves New Milestone
For Robinhood, this is a huge victory. Getting into the S&P 500 is like getting a gold star from Wall Street. It means that big investment funds, which automatically buy every stock in the index, will now have to buy shares of Robinhood. This usually pushes the stock price up.
And Robinhood’s stock has already been on a tear this year. The company, known for making stock trading easy for everyday people, has also built a strong business in crypto trading. It now has a market value close to a massive $100 billion, well above the requirement to join the S&P 500.
BREAKING: Robinhood stock, $HOOD, soars nearly +10% on news that it will be added to the S&P 500. pic.twitter.com/mIyNvCkIX3
— The Kobeissi Letter (@KobeissiLetter) September 5, 2025
When the news broke, Robinhood’s stock jumped another 10% after the market closed. Analysts say this move shows that traditional finance is slowly warming up to companies that deal with cryptocurrencies.
According to some market analysts, it is a sign of acceptance. Robinhood’s broad appeal and its move into new areas like tokenized stocks have made it impossible to ignore.
Recently, Robinhood has expanded its crypto offerings with tokenized stocks, which allow users to trade fractional shares as blockchain-based assets. This move enhances accessibility, boosts liquidity, and aligns with growing demand for digital assets.
Strategy’s Disappointing News
On the other side of the coin is Strategy. The company, which recently changed its name to “Strategy Inc.,” has been on a wild ride. It’s technically an old-school software company, but it’s now famous for one thing: buying a colossal amount of Bitcoin.
The company owns over 630,000 Bitcoins, worth roughly $70 billion. This bet has paid off handsomely, driving its market value to over $92 billion. The company is making money, and its stock trades a lot every day—on paper, it seems to check all the boxes for S&P 500 inclusion.
So why was it left out?
Experts believe the committee that picks companies for the index is nervous. They see Strategy’s deep ties to Bitcoin as a big risk.
The price of Bitcoin is famously volatile as it can swing wildly up and down in a short time. This makes Strategy’s stock incredibly volatile, too. That kind of unpredictability makes the old guard of finance uneasy.
According to experts, the committee likely sees its Bitcoin strategy as a double-edged sword. It’s the reason for their huge growth, but it also makes them a risky bet, and the S&P 500 prefers stability.
For Robinhood, this is a stamp of approval that will bring in billions of dollars from new investors and likely make its stock less bumpy.
For Strategy, the dream isn’t over. The company continues to buy more Bitcoin and remains hugely profitable from its gamble. Many analysts believe it’s only a matter of time before it gets into the index, possibly in the next rebalance expected in December.
This decision ultimately shows us where the line is currently drawn. A company that trades crypto, like Robinhood, is now mainstream enough for the biggest index. But a company that has bet its entire treasury on crypto is still seen as a step too far for the traditional financial world. For now, the gatekeepers are still choosing cautious evolution over revolution.
